Johannesburg was created 130 years ago by three guys all named George who found gold by digging pits - and the downtown still remains a pit! We were lulled into a false sense of admiration for this city since our taxi driver took the back roads from the airport due to heavy traffic. We passed lovely homes on shaded streets and all of them had guards, high fences or walls, and lots of barbed wire on the tops. All of the private schools looked grand but were also fortresses. Our hotel is in the middle of a wealthy area called Rosebank: four malls, four hotels and many, many corporate headquarters that used to be in downtown Johannesburg.
On Saturday we took the Gautrain subway from our hotel area to Park Train Station where we were to get on the hop-on hop-off bus. The subway is marvelous - clean, well maintained and well guarded. However, coming out of the subway and into the area surrounding the station was eye popping as it is in most train stations worldwide. People selling everything, people just standing around, others directing traffic and hoping for tips if they guide you to a parking place. It appears that you cross the street here as you do in Hanoi, just walk with purpose and hope people drive around you. Really chaotic!
We got onto our bus and got seats on the upper deck but under cover since we had had enough sun for one trip. Things got off to a rocky start when a woman from Spain seated behind us tried to close our window. I opened it again and said this will stay open and she tried to give us lip about going to the back of the bus where it wasn't covered if we wanted air. I just ignored her and the window stayed open. (A third of the way into the trip she was fanning herself feverishly.)
About ten minutes after the bus tour began Cindy and I were looking at each other and saying, what have we gotten into? The downtown area is, to be polite, blighted. There is litter everywhere, people sitting on the sidewalk selling old clothes and shoes, boarded-up buildings, uncontrolled traffic - and all the while we are hearing through our earbuds about how vibrant the downtown has become. All of the major banks, insurance companies and investment houses have moved their headquarters to Rosebank, and with the new buildings came the majority of the workers. So places that looked like they might have been nice apartments or condos are now filled with squatters or boarded shut. It appears that the townships have moved a lot of folks to downtown Joburg, and this is a grey and lackluster downtown. At one point in the commentary we were told that this was a horrible place for a major city. It is too high (6000 ft), it has no water source so all of the water has to be pumped in from great distances, it has no port or seaside or river and thus it is completely out of touch except by train or air.
After about an hour of navigating around the downtown we headed out to see the mining area which is simply slag heaps and red dirt that blows into the downtown on windy days. Next came some neighborhood that they said was due to be developed. I think they meant overdue. All of a sudden, out of all this rubbish and filth came the big Gold Reef City casino development, with an amusement park, a huge casino, cinemas, and hotel. What a contrast. We stopped at the Apartheid Museum, which is a lovely building, but the lines to get in were just too long for our mood. We also went past the WITS University Campus which is really beautiful and sits on a hill as a beacon of learning.
We finally got back to the starting point and missed our subway train by two minutes so we walked though the train station for about twenty minutes. The train station is a sprawling place with tons of trains coming in and out, most to the townships and a few long rail lines to faraway places like Cape Town. It was now about four and it was obvious that many people had come in from the townships and spent the day shopping and were now heading home. There were huge bags of stuff on top of women's heads, there were porters pushing their carts filled with all manner of items, and there was even a refrigerator still in its packing crate. I really wanted to wait to see how that was going to get onto the train, but it was time to head back to our hotel and we did not want to miss the Gautrain.
I think that if we had not been to Cape Town first I would not have all these negative impressions of the downtown area of Joburg, but when you see how a place like Cape Town can be run with no garbage on the streets, folks obeying traffic lights (in Cape Town they call traffic lights robots), and grand avenues that are sprinkled with parks and fountains, you just know that Joburg could do better.
That brings me to my last point: people. Until we arrived in Joburg our most intense and pleasant experience has been interacting with the people of South Africa. They have been uniformly friendly, courteous, smiling and genuinely happy to have you in their city or lodge or hotel. The people of Cape Town especially are so proud of their city and they love it when you ask them questions or tell them how beautiful the city is. Everyone was willing to go out of their way to show you around or help you with a problem. When you ate in a restaurant no fewer than three people would come over to you and ask how your day is going. Pride of place is what is missing in Joburg. You do not get many smiles, no hellos, and certainly no reliable information. There is a famous Sunday Market in Rosebank where everyone comes to get good food, local crafts, etc. I was on my morning walk and thought I would see them setting up in the park but there was nothing. I asked a security guard where it was and he didn't know what I was talking about. Five queries later to shop owners and other guards, nothing. Perhaps it is a language issue - they do not do as well with English here as they do in other parts of South Africa, despite it being one of the two languages they must learn - but I think it is more than language. It is just a lack of caring about their jobs or neighborhood or city. It is very sad, and a sad way to end a trip that has been filled with such color, sweet smiles and caring people. (I did finally find the market on the top floor of a parking garage, and it was fabulous!)
Conclusions to follow. Cindy and Wm